|

Q & A from the Grammar Hot Line -
Answers to Frequently Asked Questions
On my website is a
Grammar Hot Line, an opportunity for
you to get answers to questions about punctuation, grammar, word choice
and other puzzling matters of English usage. On this page, I have
published answers to some of the most frequently asked questions by
category:
Pronouns
| 35 |
Is there an easy way to tell whether I or
me is right in sentences like, "He gave the assignment to Mary and
___.” Is the answer any different if you say, "He gave Mary and __ the
assignment”? |
Think of it this way: He
gave the assignment to Mary, and he gave the assignment to me. You
need an object (a receiver) after the preposition "to.” Me is the
object. (I is the subject.) In your second example, the same rule
holds true. He gave Mary the assignment. He gave me the assignment.
The only difference is that here we have an indirect object after the
verb "gave.” On the other hand, if you need a subject, a performer of
the action, I is correct. ("I did the work.”) |
Verb Tense
Subject-verb Agreement
|
4 |
Which is correct?
A. Each editor has a list of guidelines that has been prepared.
B. Each editor has a list of guidelines that have been prepared.
|
Logic dictates that it’s the
singular noun list (singular) that has been prepared – so has is
correct. Because the word guidelines is located in a prepositional
phrase (of guidelines), it does not count when determining the number
of the subject. |
|
1 |
Is it:
Neither Bob nor Cathy were sure of their company’s policy on sexual
harassment. or Neither Bob nor Cathy was sure of their company’s
policy on sexual harassment. |
Was is correct.
The rule: When a compound subject is joined by either…or or
neither…nor, the verb agrees with the part of the subject closer to
it; in this case, the singular word Cathy.
|
|
2 |
"There
is intense intimacy and heart-wrenching emotions." Is or are?
|
Are is correct – but not
entirely pleasing. The structure is awkward because the compound
subject (intimacy + emotions) comes after the verb.
Better to revise: Intense intimacy and heart-wrenching emotions
heighten the drama of the film.
|
| 9 |
In this sentence is it "is" not
permitted or "are" not permitted? I'm a bit perplexed. It is the
policy of ABC Savings Bank that smoking and the use of tobacco
products (includes, but is not limited to cigarettes, cigars, chewing
tobacco, snuff and pipe smoking) is not permitted by anyone on any
property owned or leased by ABC Savings Bank. |
Because you use the word “and” after
“smoking,” you create a plural subject so “are” is correct. You
could write: It is the policy of ABC Savings Bank that the use of
tobacco products is not permitted. Use includes, but is not limited
to, cigarettes, chewing tobacco, snuff and pipe-smoking.
|
| 10 |
Do we say “40 cubic yards of contaminated
soil were excavated” or “was excavated?” I can’t remember which part
controls the number, “yards” or “soil.” |
“Yards” is the plural subject, and
“were” is the verb you want. In general, do not look into a
prepositional phrase to determine the number of the subject. But the
question is interesting because certain amounts used as amounts are
indeed considered singular subjects: “Ten acres is considered a small
piece of property in this area.”
But when the same subject is used in any other sense, the verb is
plural: “Ten acres were plowed today.” |
| 11 |
Is there a single rule I can apply to the
following examples?
One in five students was/were retained.
More than one in five students was/were retained.
Fewer than/nearly one in five students was/were retained.
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
|
You would be justified in considering the
word “one” to be the operative subject word in each case. Hence each
of these sentences has a singular subject and the verb choice should
be “was.” |
|
6 |
In the following pair, I
want to use the first option, as it feels right to me, but I cannot
explain why. I must admit that the second option seems to be the
obvious correct answer.
a. Most important was a, b and c.
b. Most important were a, b and c. |
The correct version is b.
You've inverted the sentence so the plural subject (a ,b and c)
follows the verb. Used with the verb were, the sentence sounds fine;
but if you are uncomfortable, restructure: Of all the reasons, a, b
and c are the most important. |
|
7 |
“There is intense
intimacy and heart-wrenching emotions.” Is or are? Thanks. |
Are is correct – but not
entirely pleasing. The structure is awkward because the compound
subject (intimacy + emotions) comes after the verb.
Better to revise: Intense intimacy and heart-wrenching emotions
heighten the drama of the film. |
| 32 |
A colleague drives me crazy by indicating
that "this criteria” is what we should use to judge something.
I believe criteria is a plural word. If I’m right, what is the
singular form? |
Your colleague has fallen prey to a
misunderstanding about singular and plural forms of foreign
derivatives. This word comes from Greek. Criteria is the plural form
("these criteria”) and should not be substituted for the singular
criterion ("this criterion”). |
Punctuation
|
5 |
Which of the following is
correct:
Annual Shareholders’ Meeting or Annual Shareholders Meeting
In our office we are divided on whether to use the apostrophe.
|
Annual Shareholders’
Meeting is correct. |
| 12 |
We're wondering
what is the proper way to write town-wide? Our organization is called
"Town Wide PTO,” but, of course, we have a conundrum about the correct
way to indicate that it is a group that includes representatives from
all of the schools in our town (as opposed to describing a very
expansive hamlet). We're stumped and would greatly appreciate your
advice! |
When two words
function as a single adjective, it is usually best to hyphenate:
Town-wide PTO. Interestingly, a number of "-wide"combinations are now
written as a single word -- among them worldwide, nationwide,
countrywide, countywide, citywide, communitywide, industrywide,
statewide, and storewide (although some of these look odd). So even
though I could not locate the example of townwide, I believe you have
the option of writing it the single word: Townwide PTO.
Do not write two capitalized unhyphenated words: Town Wide PTO; and,
if you hyphenate, do not capitalize "wide” as it does not have the
same weight as "Town.”. Whatever you choose, be consistent. That's the
key in many fuzzy punctuation situations. I myself prefer Town-wide
PTO. |
| 13 |
Should
well-protected be hyphenated in the following sentence? Before
entering a world where chemical hazards lie in wait, you need to be
well-protected. |
No. Well
combinations (well educated, well intended, well protected, etc.) are
not hyphenated when they come after the verb. They are hyphenated when
they precede the verb so you have well-protected employees but
employees who should be well protected. |
| 14 |
I never know
when a hyphen is needed for compound modifiers. Tell me whether
hyphens are required in these expressions:
The boat embarked on a three-hour tour.
I received a last-minute call from the President. |
Yes, the rule is
to use a hyphen when two or more words are used as a single modifier
before a noun: three-hour tour (or 3-hour tour), last-minute call,
short-term employment, up-to-date material, computer-related problem,
etc. When the same phrases are used after the verb, they are not
hyphenated.
Note: There are a few exceptions to the hyphenation requirement such
as high school teacher, credit card customer, data entry clerk. |
| 15 |
I was recently
married and have a new surname – Hughes. Please tell me how the plural
of Hughes should be written and also how to show possession. |
You’ve touched a sensitive
chord for many people whose names end in the letters s and z and
require a new syllable to pluralize. One must say Hugheses or Joneses
and, therefore, add es. As for possession, if one Hughes is doing the
possessing, add ’s. (Sandra Hughes’s decision). If several Hugheses
are doing the possessing, use an apostrophe after the plural form (
the Hugheses’ party). To many people, the correct versions look
offensive. (“That’s not my name,” they complain.) To them, I suggest
restructuring the sentence: The Hughes family made the decision.
|
| 16 |
What do you do for the
plural of an acronym? Take this sentence: There will be a strong and
swift movement toward “Pay-for-performance compensation,” not only for
CEOs (or CEO’s) but across all levels of public and private companies. |
CEOs is the preferred form.
According to today’s standards, capital letters are made plural by
adding s without an apostrophe: CEOs, PTAs, HMOs, unless confusion
could occur because a new word is created: He received all A’s.
Yet some authorities still suggest the use of an apostrophe before the
s: CEO’s, PTA’s, HMO’s. For clarity’s sake, uncapitalized letters and
abbreviations form their plural with an apostrophe: Mind your p’s and
q’s. |
| 17 |
Would clean up be
one or two words when used as an adjective, i.e. Clean Up Day?
|
We used to prefer
hyphenation – Clean-Up Day or Clean-up day – but contemporary use
seems to favor Cleanup Day. There is no hard and fast rule. Because
it’s an adjective, the words are not simply separated without
hyphenation as in Clean Up Day. Of course, if I ask you to clean
up your room, I am using a verb form – no hyphen.
|
| 18 |
My company recently ran
an ad with the following sentence:
“Our company has over 120 years experience in the horticultural
industry.”
Of course, I would have preferred that they put an “of” between
“years” and “experience”. But they didn’t, and now I’m wondering if
there should be an apostrophe after the “s” is the word “years” in the
above sentence. Should it be, “Our company has over 120 years’
experience….”? What do think?
|
The sentence as it is
written requires an apostrophe after “years” – 120 years’ experience.
It follows the rule that regular plural words (ending in s for the
plural) form the possessive by adding an apostrophe. In this case, the
word “years” has a possessive relationship to experience and is
punctuated just like 120 managers’ experience or 120 horses’
experience. |
| 19 |
I am addressing a
letter to:
Mr. John Smith III
1234 Coconut Drive
Honolulu, Hawaii 96843
Dear Mr. Smith III: or should it be Dear Mr. Smith:
|
Correct version: Dear Mr.
Smith: |
| 33 |
I’m responsible for a
monthly newsletter from my church. Do I need a comma between month and
year when I put the date of the issue – May, 2006 or May 2006?
|
May 2006 is correct. Do not
use a comma unless a day is included: May 15, 2006 |
| 34 |
Public holidays with
possessives before the word Day are punctuated in various ways. For
example, I’ve seen Veteran’s Day Veterans’ Day, and Veterans Day. The
same goes for Mothers Day, Fathers Day,
even Grandparents Day. Is it OK to write them without punctuation? |
Good question. There are
many discrepancies in current usage (reflected also in the greeting
cards and advertised sales related to those holidays!) According to
the Merriam Webster Dictionary, the correct forms are as follows:
Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Veterans Day, Presidents’ Day,
Grandparents’ Day. Both Valentine’s Day and Valentines Day are
correct.
|
| 20 |
Please let me
know if you agree with the usage of the apostrophe in this sentence:
There will be strong and swift movement toward pay for performance
compensation, not only for CEO’s but across all levels of public and
private companies. |
Do not use an
apostrophe. Write CEOs. Capital letter abbreviations are pluralized by
adding s alone. |
| |
|
|
Choosing the Right Word
| 21 |
My question:
how to use first or firstly. I’ve seen secondly at times, but it seems
odd to me that first is used. Somehow, I feel like firstly matches
secondly. But I don’t see people use it this way. |
The correct form
for indicating a list of items: first, second, third. Do not tack on
the –ly, even on the word second. It’s simply incorrect. The same is
true for last (never lastly) and thus (never thusly).
|
|
22 |
Is the
following sentence grammatically correct?
Our Surgery Department has got you covered. |
Most authorities frown on
the use of got to mean “have.”
“I’ve got a secret” is better written as “I have a secret.” In your
example, it would be better to write: “Our Surgery Department has you
covered.” To use got isn’t to commit a gross grammatical error, but it
does reflect loose—or colloquial -- use of the language. “Colloquial”
suggests that it’s OK to use orally but not in writing.
The word got has legitimate meanings and is fine to use in examples
such as the following:
I don’t get it. Get me out of here! Try to get
him to change his mind.
Avoid the use of gotten. |
| 23 |
When I use an
acronym in a sentence, is the use of a or an before the acronym
determined by the sound of the letter or the actual word it
represents: a MIT graduate or an MIT graduate?
|
Usage is
determined by how one expects the sentence to be read. It’s highly
likely that one will pronounce the letters em-eye-tee, not
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, so logic dictates that an is
correct. |
| 24 |
Which is more correct to use?
a. I expect Misters George Brennan and Kevin Foley to be with us
beginning on May 11, 2009.
b. I expect Mr. George Brennan and Mr. Kevin Foley to be with us
beginning on May 11, 2009
|
Use b because it sounds more
contemporary and expected in today’s business environment.
Version a is reserved for very formal use; and the title to be used,
from the French, is Messrs. (not Misters).
|
| 25 |
Do you refer to a 55-foot diameter
tank or a 55-feet diameter tank?
I think the first is correct, but I’m not sure.
|
The first is correct –
a 55-foot diameter tank. Of course, you could write it in another way:
The tank has a 55-foot diameter. The tank is 55 feet in diameter.
|
| 26 |
Reoccurrence and recurrence – are
they both words, and is there any difference between them? |
Yes, both are words.
Reoccurrence refers to a one-time repetition: Despite a guarantee that
the problem was solved, there was a reoccurrence one week later.
Recurrence refers to more than one repetition: Although the leak has
been fixed temporarily, we are prepare for a recurrence of the
problem. |
|
31 |
I recently saw a reference to "an historical occasion.” I was
always taught to use "a” before a hard h (a
house, a helper) and "an” before an h that isn’t pronounced
(an hour, an herb). Has the rule changed?
|
You are correct in your thinking that
"a”
should be used before "history” or any other derivations of the word. The
popularity of "an” comes from British usage whereby a word beginning with a
weakly pronounced h is preceded by an. Thus you might hear "an
historian, "an habitual offender,” or "an heroic ode.” In
America today, the use of "a” is widespread and definitely preferred.
|
| |
|
|
General
|
3 |
When closing a
business letter, do all words begin with a capital letter – or only
the first? For example, should I write In Strength and Unity or In
strength and unity?
|
The rule is
to capitalize only the first word, so In strength and unity (followed
by a comma) is correct. In general, it is wise to use standard
closings like Sincerely. |
| 8 |
Is this sentence correct?
I wanted to make sure you’re still scheduled to go. Or, should it be -
I wanted to make sure you were still scheduled to go? |
Best – if this is what you mean: I
want to make sure you are still scheduled to go.
You are not wrong to mix tenses; it really depends on what you
logically want to say. Many people write or say, “I just wanted to
make sure…” when they mean, “I just want to make sure…”
Logically, what follows is that you are scheduled, not that you were
scheduled.
My concern is for precision; that is, what you say must reflect what
you mean. |
| 27 |
I’m not sure if
there is an understood “an” and “the” in the following sentences: The boxes were blocking a fire extinguisher and electric panel.
Or is it: The boxes were blocking a fire extinguisher and an
electrical panel.
A similar problem occurs with the word “the”:
The boxes were blocking the fire extinguisher and electrical panel.
Or is it: The boxes were blocking the fire extinguisher and the
electrical panel.
Can you get away without using the second “the” or “an”? |
You must write “a
fire extinguisher and an electric panel because there is a required
word change from “a.” to “an,” due to the fact that the word electric
begins with a vowel. You can get away with one “the” as long as it is
clear that you are talking about two separate items (fire extinguisher
and electric panel). For clarity’s sake, it might be wiser to repeat:
the fire extinguisher and the electric panel. |
| 28 |
When do the seasons require a capital
letter? |
Do not capitalize names of seasons in
general use: We will promote the product next spring.
Capitalize in special contexts such as when used with a date (the Fall
2009 issue) or as a title (the Winter Olympics). |
| 29 |
When writing the time, which version is
correct – a.m., am, or A.M.? |
The preferred form is lower case,
punctuated, and closed spacing; a.m., p.m. Always use with figures: 8
a.m. or 8:00 a.m. Usage varies and you will see all three forms.
Whatever you do, be consistent.
|
| 30 |
Please comment on the frequently used
expression "general consensus
of opinion.” |
All you need is the word consensus, meaning
"opinion of a group”: "The consensus was to go forward with the
plan.” The words "general” and "of opinion” are indeed redundant.
|
|
| |
|

Suggest
a topic for Susan Kline to address
Susan Kline of Business Communications consults with
and trains people in business to help them send professional messages
that are clear, concise and correct. Her clients number among the most
effective communicators in their fields. How can your organization
benefit from Ms. Kline’s support?
Contact Us.
|
|